The Great Halloween Problem Solved!

Posted · 2 Comments
Halloween Candy Alternatives for Health

I love this time of year.  How could you not?  Crisp fall air, changing leaves, and Halloween on the way.  It’s the only time of year that it is acceptable to decorate with skulls and play heavy music!  It’s so much fun.

When I began my fitness career, I really struggled with Halloween.  It is kind of funny to me now, but I had some major concerns to reconcile.  I grew up in an obese household worshipping the candy aspect of Halloween.

Our culture is driven by junk food, sweets, and candy at every holiday, event, and happy or sad occasion.  Which means “treats” (an occasional indulgence) aren’t really treats any longer and there are almost daily opportunities to eat something unwise.

So for a few years, I was paralyzed by Halloween.  Losing my father to obesity at over 400 pounds and seeing my mother at just under 400 pounds at her heaviest made a real impression on me.  Our choices determine the body we live in – it is simply not mostly genetic. And it’s our day-to-day choices that matter the most.  Not what you do on any one given day.

The paralysis manifested itself by “skipping” Halloween and not handing out anything.  I kept the house dark and watched horror movies or I would go out.  But still I wanted to participate in the holiday.  I just needed a few years to figure it out.  Here are some tips to give out some candy and some cool stuff to take a step toward health instead of horror for the trick-or-treaters in your neighborhood.

  • Give out candy that is only made from real food. Think a small number of ingredients, minimal to no colorings, and contains nuts or coconut and perhaps darker chocolate and a sensible amount of sugar.  Stuff like licorice, candy corn, and most hard candy would be out.  These items aren’t food.  They are edible, but not food.

  • Go to the dollar store and pick up some packages of super balls, mini dinosaurs, spider rings or other simple and fun toys. Mix them all into the bowl with whatever candy you choose.  You will be amazed at the number of kids that pick some of the toys.  (Even they realize they have enough candy already!)
  • Visit an international/ethnic grocery store or the international aisle of your standard grocery store and pick up some candy options that are less traditional. You could pick a single country’s chocolates and inform the kids that take any of them where they are from.   You’ll give them a good story about where the candy is from and may spark an interest in seeing where the country is on a map.

  • At home, eliminate sodas, fruit juices, candy, and chips from your family’s diet for the week or two before or after Halloween to allow for the candy consumption by your own kids from their trick-or-treating.

  • IMPORTANT: Store the Halloween candy in a difficult to reach place in the kitchen – either high or low in a cabinet. Do not store it at shoulder height or in a visible bowl!  It will get eaten faster than it should be. 

Yes, these tips take a little more effort than simply buying massive bags of the worst candy.  But only a little more effort and it is worth it.  Children often learn bigger lessons from subtle, daily, seemingly small choices of the adults around them rather than the “big” lessons we try to overtly teach them.

Be creative in how you celebrate this fun holiday and you just might send the message that “fun” doesn’t always have to equal “fun size.”

2 Responses to "The Great Halloween Problem Solved!"
  1. I am fortunate that my kids never really finished their Halloween candy; they paced themselves and lost interest quickly. The downside of this is that mice would locate the candy stash and have quite a party. So I would add a tip to this–perhaps store a portion of the candy in the freezer. Maybe you will forget about it, and you can throw it out after a month or so, and no one will miss it.

    • Jonathan says:

      Yes! Put the candy in the freezer right next to (or even underneath) those frozen peas that sit there forever and no one picks up! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *